Toast Coffee + Kitchen in bustling Bay Shore is a darling among brunch lovers, known for its expansive menu, lively atmosphere, and standout coffee. A branch of the popular Long Island chain founded in Port Jefferson in 2002, this location features a bright, café‑diner aesthetic with room to linger and a community‑centered vibe .

Their menu is loaded with creative breakfast and lunch offerings—Churro or Blueberry Peach Cobbler Pancakes, Momlette with burrata and shrimp, Crispy Tostones Benedict, and the Toast Smash Burger (sirloin-brisket, comeback sauce) among others. They also offer vegetarian and kids’ selections, fresh-baked muffins and bagels, plus seasonal spin on classics like Churro French Toast “Deep Fried French Toast”.

For drinks, Toast delivers top-tier coffee—including seasonal lattes like Churro and mushroom-infused Chaga‑ccino—as well as boozy brunch cocktails and mimosa flights.

Bay Shore residents and Long Islanders frequently suggest Toast as one of the best brunch spots—a trusted pick thanks to consistently good food and coffee, despite weekend crowds . The staff-paced waiting system lets you explore downtown while you wait.

Restaurants reviews describe Toast as offering “bold flavours, playful cocktails, and unexpected twists on your favorite brunch classics,” with a “mid-morning vibe” and friendly, efficient service.

Why you’ll love it:

  • Inventive menu—sweet and savory brunch dishes
  • Excellent coffee with seasonal specials
  • Spacious, energetic ambiance in Central Bay Shore
  • Popular community gathering spot, with loyalty rewards
Bottom line: Toast Coffee + Kitchen is Bay Shore’s go-to brunch hub—offering a lively mix of creative comfort food, standout coffees/cocktails, and a warm, social atmosphere. Perfect for a weekend morning indulgence or casual midday catch‑up with friends.