Bayshore
Gateway to Fire Island, Packed Main Street, and Solid Food from Brunch to Oysters.
What Bay Shore Is About
Bay Shore, NY is a lively South Shore destination known for its vibrant downtown, award-winning restaurants, and easy access to Fire Island ferries. Visitors can stroll Main Street for boutique shopping, explore the marina, or enjoy family time at local parks. The town is also home to the South Shore Mall, one of Long Island’s major shopping centers, making Bay Shore a hub for both local businesses and national retailers. With waterfront dining, craft breweries, seasonal events, and plenty of shopping, Bay Shore offers the perfect mix of small-town charm and big-city convenience.
Bay Shore Best Places to Eat & Drink
The LakeHouse
Offers creative New American cuisine and views of the marina
Salt & Barrel
Oyster bar, craft cocktails, seasonal seafood.
Tula Kitchen
Health-forward plates and good vegetarian options.
Local Burger Co.
Casual comfort, solid beer list.
Verde
Mexican plates and margaritas (great for groups).
BayShore Entertainment & Nightlife
Coastal Kitchen & Daiquiri Bar – Known for frozen cocktails and weekend DJs, this downtown hotspot is always busy with a fun, young crowd.
Changing Times – A classic Long Island sports bar that shifts into a lively hangout at night, with music, drinks, and plenty of energy.
Great South Bay Brewery – A massive brewery that doubles as an entertainment venue, with live bands, trivia nights, and food trucks.
Kitty Mulligan’s Irish Pub – Cozy and spirited with a mix of live bands, hearty Irish fare, and regular events like bingo and trivia.
Alive by the Bay – A seasonal summer block party on Main Street with live music, food vendors, and open-air fun for all ages.
Shopping & Local Businesses
Bay Shore, NY has transformed into one of Long Island’s busiest downtowns, and part of its charm comes from the mix of independent shops and small businesses lining Main Street and the side streets near the marina. Shoppers will find everything from stylish clothing boutiques to vintage treasures and unique gift shops.
Highlights include Maple Avenue Trading, a locally loved spot for home décor, gifts, and accessories, and The Posh Boutique, which offers women’s fashion with a modern edge. Music fans can browse vinyl records and collectibles at Record Stop, a Long Island institution that relocated to nearby Patchogue but still has roots in Bay Shore. For those who enjoy one-of-a-kind pieces, Clothing Arts Collective features local designers and handcrafted apparel.
Bay Shore also leans into lifestyle businesses: One Main Yoga offers wellness in the heart of downtown, while Salt & Steel blends a surf-inspired boutique with coastal style clothing and accessories. In the warmer months, Bay Shore comes alive with street fairs and pop-up markets, giving local makers and artisans a chance to showcase handmade crafts, food products, and art.
From shopping for fashion and gifts to browsing markets and lifestyle shops, Bay Shore’s small business scene adds another layer of personality to its growing reputation as a must-visit South Shore destination.
BayShore Parks & Outdoors
Bay Shore Marina — Docks, breezes, and ferry access.
Fire Island Ferries — Ocean Beach, Kismet, and more.
Gardiner County Park — Flat trail to a quiet bay beach (dog-friendly).
Bayard Cutting Arboretum (nearby Great River) — Mansion grounds, easy riverside paths.
Bay Shore, NY is one of Long Island’s fastest-growing downtowns, offering the perfect mix of waterfront charm, a thriving restaurant scene, and a lively shopping and nightlife district. Located on the South Shore of Suffolk County, Bay Shore has become a go-to destination for locals and visitors looking for great dining, entertainment, and easy access to Fire Island.
Downtown Bay Shore is centered around Main Street, where you’ll find award-winning restaurants, trendy bars, and boutique shops that give the area a unique personality. Favorites like The LakeHouse, Salt & Barrel, and Tullulah’s draw food lovers from across Long Island, while cozy cafés, ice cream shops, and bakeries provide plenty of casual options for families. Bay Shore is also home to Great South Bay Brewery, one of Long Island’s most popular craft breweries, making it a hotspot for beer enthusiasts and weekend hangouts.
For outdoor lovers, Bay Shore offers easy access to the Great South Bay with its beautiful marina and ferry service to Fire Island. Families can enjoy a day at Gardiner County Park, a dog-friendly park with scenic trails leading to the bay, or visit Bayard Cutting Arboretum in nearby Great River for gardens, historic grounds, and riverfront views. Seasonal events like Alive by the Bay, a summer block party featuring live music and food vendors, highlight the community’s fun and welcoming spirit.
Shopping in Bay Shore also adds to its appeal. Along with Main Street boutiques like Maple Avenue Trading and surf-inspired shops such as Salt & Steel, the town regularly hosts pop-up markets and street fairs that showcase local artists and makers. Whether you’re looking for fashion, gifts, or home décor, Bay Shore offers plenty of ways to shop local.
With its mix of fine dining, casual eateries, waterfront attractions, small businesses, and nightlife, Bay Shore has earned its reputation as one of the best downtowns on Long Island. From date nights and brunch with friends to family outings and Fire Island getaways, Bay Shore, NY delivers a complete Long Island experience.