When it comes to beating the Long Island heat, nothing hits like a cold scoop of premium ice cream. Whether you’re on a weekend drive through the East End or walking through your favorite downtown, these standout shops serve more than just dessert—they deliver a full-on experience. From homemade classics to outrageous seasonal flavors, we’ve rounded up five ice cream spots across Long Island that are worth every bite (and brain freeze). If you’re searching for the best ice cream on Long Island, this list will point you straight to the scoop.
Snowflake Ice Cream Shoppe - Riverhead, NY
📍 1148 West Main St, Riverhead, NY 11901
⭐ Google rating: 4.8★ (based on 1,339 reviews)
Family-run since 1953, Snowflake is a roadside legend known for massive portions, classic shakes, and rotating “flavor of the week” creations. Their pistachio‑flavored soft serve and old-school sodas deliver nostalgia with a modern twist—perfect for beating the East End heat.
Magic Fountain Ice Cream – Mattituck
📍 9825 Main Rd, Mattituck, NY 11952
⭐ Google rating: 4.8★ (based on ~985 reviews)
This North Fork staple offers over 50 homemade flavors—from bold staples like Cherry Bourbon to quirky special editions like Goat Cheese and Saffron. Friendly service, quirky seasonal specials, and long lines year-round make it a must-stop for adventurous sweet seekers.
Krisch’s Restaurant & Ice Cream Parlour – Massapequa
📍 11 Central Ave, Massapequa, NY 11758
⭐ Google rating: ~4.8★ (based on 1,887 reviews)
Open since 1955, Krisch’s doubles as a retro diner and sundae destination. Known for its massive “Kitchen Sink” challenge sundae, classic milkshakes, and vintage diner vibe, it’s the place to go when you want sugar overload in nostalgic style.
Mickey’s Ice Cream Kitchen – St. James
📍 370 Lake Ave, St. James, NY 11780
⭐ Google rating: 4.9★ (based on ~215 reviews)
This bright and clean shop is beloved for its made-from-scratch flavors, generous free toppings, and vegan-friendly options. With indoor-outdoor seating, event nights, and a friendly vibe, it’s a hit with families and creators alike.
Mia’s Ice Cream Kitchen – Centereach
📍 1315 Middle Country Rd, Unit 5, Centereach, NY 11720
⭐ Google rating: ~4.5★ (Yelp) / ~4.8★
Known for its artisan churned flavors and standout vegan options, Mia’s is a Centereach gem. Think airy pistachio, tangy lemongrass coconut, and classics done right—served by a welcoming team that lets you taste before you pick.